Londonderry Airbrushed

Recently, a photo of the statue of Charles William Stewart or Lord Londonderry (1778–1854), in Durham city’s marketplace was posted in a local Facebook group. Someone commented that he “owned many of the coal mines in County Durham and spent lots of money to make them run better.” Astonishingly, it transpired that this particular piece of misinformation was taken from a website produced by the university for use in local schools. Not wishing to allow this go unchallenged, I responded by making a few factual observations and suggestions.

First of all, Londonderry was brutal even by the standards of his time. On the Tory benches in the House of Lords, he led the opposition to the Mines Act 1842, which among other things, prevented boys under the age of 10 years old from working underground. Thankfully, he failed, although he did manage to get the legislation watered down. Therefore, the often-heard claim that we cannot condemn historical figures because “people didn’t know any better at the time” simply does not apply. It is no exaggeration to describe Londonderry as a tyrant. In 1844, when miners went on strike, he evicted them and their families from their homes. He also issued his infamous ‘Seaham Letter’ which warned that any local traders who provided strikers with credit would be driven out of business. A few years later, he strongly opposed the 1850 Coal Mines Inspection Act which ensured that mines were subject to government safety inspections.

Unsurprisingly, given this record, Londonderry was not well liked by many colliers and their families in County Durham. It was his family who paid to have his imposing statue put up in the market square in 1861. So, like many of our public monuments, it was not put there by popular demand.

We are often told that these monuments are vital in order for us to remember the past. But given that none of this factual information is included on the statue, how can it be considered educational? What is more, why are we still celebrating someone who enriched themselves on the back of exploiting men, women, and children in County Durham? When someone is literally put on a pedestal it is difficult to argue that this represents some kind of neutral act of remembrance.

It would be far better to have a monument to a miner or a miners’ union leader such as Thomas Hepburn, who tried to put a stop to such brutalities. At the very least, some of this information should be included on the statue’s plinth so that the public can make an informed decision as to whether this statue should still take pride of place. Londonderry’s presence in Durham city’s centre demonstrates that in most cases, monuments of the ‘great and the good’ are not about genuinely educating people about history but celebrating our ‘betters’ and whitewashing history in the process.

Standard

7 thoughts on “Londonderry Airbrushed

  1. Lynn Gibson says:

    Brilliant Paul! Maybe we need to start a petition to either have the statue removed, or at least a historically accurate detailed information plaque on the plinth!

  2. Pingback: Lord Londonderry statue celebrates enslaving of Miners, their children, and Irish people – The Free

  3. David Walsh says:

    Yes, and for the motley group of knuckle draggers who turned up the other weekend to ostensibly “defend “his statue as he “was a brave soldier” they should be told that he was so useless a commander in the Peninsular campaign that Wellington had to sack him on the spot. Mind, succeeding generations of Vane Stewarts were little better. See my past essay on Charles, a Tory government minister of the 1930’s and a pal of Hitler and Ribbentrop. http://republic-of-teesside.blogspot.com/2013/01/a-right-little-charlie_31.html?q=wynyard

  4. John McCue says:

    Good work, Paul. I knew Londonderry was a landowner but didn’t know he was a mining businessman. There are ways of running businesses to build a regional economy and provide jobs in an enlightened way, building trust, morale and health among employees. Exploiting your workforce is unacceptable, but it’s still going on – Amazon, Uber, Sports Direct…..

  5. Anne Lamb says:

    As a miner’s daughter I was taken with my father to Durham Big Meeting every year. On viewing the statue in the centre of Durham market place my dad commented that the miners in County Durham hated that man. I did not understand what he meant but gradually came to know how he treated miners and understood the hatred. Curiously after the latest news where there have been massive demonstrations and pulling down of statues my thoughts returned to the statue of Lord Londonderry. At one point when miners were on strike , he ordered that they be put out from their houses. They were living where they could in the middle of Winter. When he found out that the miners were drawing water from the local stream, he ordered soldiers to dam the stream as a means of breaking the strike. Miners in County Durham will never forget his outright cruelty.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s